Noam Chomsky

Aaaah, Noam Chomsky. Once I got over the incredible 80s-ness of the film, I found Chomsky’s thoughts in ‘Manufacturing Consent’ quite compelling – particularly his thoughts on propaganda. In the film Chomsky discusses how historically society was controlled in many aspects of people’s daily lives, but when personal freedom became more prevalent governments turned to propaganda to coerce people into thinking a certain way. He goes on to compare today’s media as propaganda and I couldn’t agree more. If you’ve read my blog at all you can probably tell that I struggle with media messages. I watch MTV and other equally useless crap and until I started taking this class, not once did I question the messages they were portraying. I think if Chomsky were to watch MTV today he would collapse. Actually, if he were to watch anything on television he would speechless. I find it incredible that so many years ago he was able to make so many intuitive and intelligent inferences about the media. I believe that we are currently part of the most media-saturated generation that has ever lived, so I find it comforting that people like Chomsky thought the way he did, but I’m also frustrated that more people don’t know about it. Media consciousness is so important and I think it’s far too often overlooked as a teaching tool.

**It has come to my attention that Chomsky is not actually dead… For some reason I wrote down in my notes from last class that Paul said he was. And so my post probably sounds pretty weird. My bad!!***

Apocalypto: A Sociological Experiment

For this assignment I was planning on going to a major film on its opening night in hopes that I could see as many people as possible during their movie-going experience. However, a few weeks before this assignment was due, I went to a movie and decided I just had to use it as the subject of this paper. I went to the Mel Gibson film “Apocalypto” at the Movie Mill. It was a Friday night during “Midnight Movie Madness”, so the film didn’t start until 12:30am. Having said that, the theatre was quite empty. Although I didn’t go to the movie with this assignment in mind, after I got home and started thinking about the whole experience, I knew that it would work quite well for this paper.

After reading Russell Smith’s article from the Globe and Mail, I couldn’t help but be angry. He came off as being the most miserable, pompous, dramatic man I had ever read anything from. Smith not only spent a good 500 words spelling out his intense hatred of movie going, but he also made it explicitly clear that he is a pessimistic grouch. It’s easy to say that his article made me as mad as he felt when he went to the theatre. Needless to say, I interpret movie-going much differently than Smith does.

It was just before midnight when we got to the theatre. I had expected a really poor turnout and that it would mostly be college-aged people in attendance. On top of that, I figured most people wouldn’t be seeing the movie we were since who wants to read sub-titles for two and a half hours in the middle of the night? Apparently, seven of us do. We got in line to buy our tickets and I was shocked to see the people in front of us carrying a baby. Don’t babies go to bed earlier than midnight? And if they were asleep, wouldn’t the extremely high volume of the film wake them up? I thought that was a little strange. We waited to get into the theatre for probably about 10 minutes or so. There was a good thirty to forty people waiting in the lobby for their theatre to open up and I must say I didn’t see a single person gorging on super buttery popcorn or drinking a gallon-sized cup of Coke. People chatted with each other and glanced ever so often at the ticket booth to see if they could go in yet.

Finally we got into the theatre and sat in our ever-so comfy seats. Here is where I start loving the movie experience and disagreeing in every way with Russell Smith. I absolutely love going to movies. I enjoy every aspect of it. The seats are comfortable, theatres are now designed so that nobody’s huge head is obstructing your view, and it’s extremely dark. Nothing pleases me more than watching a movie in complete darkness. Even when we’re at home watching movies, most people turn out majority, if not all, of the lights (though I’m sure Russell Smith watches them in broad daylight with every single light on). We took off our jackets to get more comfortable and quietly took our “contraband” snacks which we pre-purchased as Super Sam out of our purses and jacket pockets and munched away. The thing with the Movie Mill is that you don’t get that fun trivia before your film starts. Smith hates this part, but I love the movie trivia. It makes the time fly by before the movie gets going. However, I was not so lucky to have this luxury. The Movie Mill plays really poorly funded ads and PowerPoint presentations from local business before the movie starts. I don’t mind the first go-around, but after that I get sick of seeing that real estate agent who advertises himself as being John Travolta (does that work? Do people hire him based on the fact that he looks like John Travolta?). So instead I people watch.

There was an older couple two rows in front of us that sat in the end seats. They shared a popcorn and did not speak a word to each other before, during, or after the movie. You could tell that they had been together long enough that silence was comfortable and they were just enjoying a nice night out of the house. The next two movie goers who walked in were two guys, probably in their early twenties. Their seating arrangement really intrigued me. They sat so that there was a one-seat “buffer” between them. I call this extra and completely unnecessary seat a “buffer” because I can only assume that this seat is being used so that it doesn’t appear to anyone else in the theatre that they are on a date. This blew my mind. If they’re so uncomfortable going to a movie with each other, then maybe they should just stay at home. It is presumptuous of me to make this claim, but I really cannot think of another reason for the “buffer seat”.

Apocalypto is a typical Mel Gibson creation. It is violent and bloody, yet at the same time, completely captivating. I thoroughly enjoyed the movie. There were numerous times that I gasped out loud and I can’t even count how many times I covered my eyes due to the graphic scenes. The other patrons were doing the same thing, even the two guys NOT on a date. This is another reason I love going to movies in the theatre. The massive screens allow everything to come to life and get right in your face. There is no escaping the emotions, actions, and music on screen. I couldn’t disagree with Russell Smith’s article more. I think that having people talk during movies, the sticky floors, the overpriced concession food, and the anticipation of waiting for the lights to dim is an experience that cannot be matched. Whether there is seven people or three hundred people in theatre, it’s sure to be an experience far greater than one you could have in your own living room at home.

TV, eh?

There’s one article from Chapter 5 that really got me thinking. In the writing about Steve Smith (better known as Red Green) he discusses the flooding of the Canadian television market with American shows. In it he mentions a number of things that struck a chord with me. For one, he said that Canadian stations are judged on the amount or quality of American shows they can import, and I couldn’t agree more. As far as I’m concerned there are 3 Canadian stations: CTV, Global, and CBC. And that’s the order I would also rank them in quality. I never ever ever watch CBC. I do sometimes watch CBC Newsworld so that i can watch “The Hour” with George Stromboulopolous. But I rarely think “I wonder what’s on CBC tonight” because my answer would always be “nothing good.” I associate CBC with nature shows, news shows, and bad Canadian sketch comedy.

Smith says that with “Canadians being constantly bombarded with American culture, there’s a natural tendency to assimilate and, with Canadians, if all they’re exposed to is American media, they will become more and more like Americans and less like Canadians.” I find this point to be veeery fascinating. What makes us Canadian? There are 5 things that I feel make me Canadian, besides of course my legal citizenship:

1. Love of Tim Hortons. I know that sounds like a joke, but i’m dead serious. Canadians love tims the way Americans love their KFC or whatever. And if it’s cold outside, like today, all I want is a tims hot chocolate. It’s in our blood.

2. Hockey. I went to a Flames game in LA in November and it was a completely different experience. My friend and I went to a bar in the Staples Center before the game and it was packed with LA Kings fans. The difference between a bar pre-hockey game in LA than in Calgary? Everyone in the bar was glued to tv watching a football game. And college football to boot. Another strange thing? At the game there were well over 3 dozen people that we saw wearing jerseys for other teams. These teams were not playing. So why would you wear a Red Wings jersey to a Flames vs Kings game???!? That’s just silly!

3. Pride. Americans are proud of their country. Why, I do not know, but they are. So are Canadians. I feel that it’s a completely different pride though. Americans are in your face, tshirt/bumper sticker/flag wearing patriots. We are just proud deep inside and only show this affection in public when we go to Europe and we sew a flag on our backpack. We’re awesome and we don’t need to rub in people’s face.

4. Beer. No explanation needed.

5. Not hated. As a whole I don’t feel that Canadians are dislike worldwide. Americans are, but we are peace promoting, friendly people.

So after all that, what is my point? I don’t think that watching American shows is going to take any of that away from us. Although our two countries are so similar in a lot of ways, we are also drastically different. Like when I enter a house, I take off my shoes. Why? Cuz I’m not rude and dirty. Anyways, I think Steve Smith made some interesting points and if you didn’t read the little blurb on him in the text, you should. I just think Canadian Entertainment moguls are a little touchy and are taking it all to seriously. It’s television.